ãŸããããšåºè«ïŒœãã-2
ã3ããååãšããŠã®è³åŽåããããé£æºçµç¹ã«ãããå ±é ¬ããž
ãã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã¯ã瀟äŒåé¡ã®æ žå¿ãïŒä»¥äžãæ¬èãšç¥ãïŒã®å šäœãéããäžåç¯åããã瀟äŒææ©äœã«ãããŠã¯çèšç¶æãç®çãšããè³éåŽåïŒè ïŒã¯æ¶æ» ããããããåŽåãæ¬æ¥ã®å§¿ã§ãã粟ç¥ç掻ãšããŠæç«ãããšã®å±æãæããŠã¿ãããè¿ä»£è³æ¬äž»çŸ©ç€ŸäŒã«æãŸããã£ãç§ãã¡ã«ã¯ãäœãéæ¹ããªãæ§æ³ãªã®ã ããã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã®èªèª¿ã¯ç¢ºåºããã€ã¡ãŒãžã«åºã¥ããŠãã
ãç§èªèº«ãã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã®èããâŠâŠç€ŸäŒäž»çŸ©çãªçç£æ段ã®å ¬æåã«ãããªããè³éåŽåïŒè ïŒã®æ¶æ» ãããããã¯ãçèšç¶æãç®çãšããªãã粟ç¥ç掻ãšããŠã®åŽåããšããã€ã¡ãŒãžããªããªãäºè§£ã§ãããæ¬æžã幟床ãªãèªã¿è¿ããšãšãã«é¢é£æžç±ãèªãããšãšãªã£ããããã§ã¯ããã®èŸºããå·¡ã£ãŠæžãèšãããšã«ããããŸãã¯ããªããè³éåŽåïŒè ïŒã®æ¶æ» ããªã®ãâŠâŠã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒæ¬¡ã®ããã«è¿°ã¹ãã
ãé£æºçµç¹ã«ã¯ããè³éåŽåè ãã¯ååšããªããè³éåŽåè ã®å±ããçµåã¯ã¿ãããã®åã«ãã£ãŠäŒæ¥å®¶ããã§ããã ãé«ãè³éãèŠæ±ããã®ã§ããããé£æºçµç¹ã®åŽåè ã¯ãäŒæ¥å®¶ãæ¶è²»è ãšäžç·ã«åããæ¥çžŸã«å¿ããå ±é ¬ãåããããã®ããšã¯çµåã«ãããè°äŒæ¿æ²»çãªè°æ±ºã«ãã£ãŠã¯çããªãããïŒãçµæžç掻ã«ãããé£æºçµç¹ãp-xxii-xxiiiïŒ
ãã€ãŸããè¿ä»£è³æ¬äž»çŸ©ç€ŸäŒã«ããããååãšããŠã®è³éåŽåãããäžåç¯ããã瀟äŒææ©äœã«ããããé£æºçµç¹ã«ãããå ±é ¬ããžã®è»¢æãããè³éåŽåïŒè ïŒã®æ¶æ» ããªã®ã§ãããã§ã¯ããã®ãé£æºçµç¹ããšã¯ãªã«ãâŠâŠã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã¯æ¬¡ã®ããã«è¿°ã¹ãã
ãçµæžç掻ã¯åœå®¶å¶åºŠããããåœå®¶äž»çŸ©ãããç¬ç«ããŠãèªåèªèº«ã®åã§çºå±ããããšããŠããããããããããããšãã§ããã®ã¯ãæ¶è²»è ãšæµéæ¥è ãšçç£è ã®è«žå£äœããçµæžç芳ç¹ã«åŸã£ãŠãåœå®¶ããç¬ç«ããŠãé£æºçµç¹ã圢æãããšãã®ã¿ã§ããããïŒãçµæžç掻ã«ãããé£æºçµç¹ãp-xxiïŒ
ãæãé£æºçµç¹ã®å éšã§ã¯ãå°éç¥èãäºå®èªèã«ãã£ãŠå©å®³é¢ä¿ãå æ¬çã«èª¿æŽããããæ³åŸã財ã®çç£ã埪ç°ãæ¶è²»ãèŠå¶ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããå人ãã°ã«ãŒãã®çŽæ¥çæŽå¯ãå©å®³é¢ä¿ããããããèŠå¶ãããé£æºçµç¹ç掻ã®äžã§äººã³ãšãå¿ èŠãªæŽå¯ãããŠãããã«ããããšã倧åãªã®ã§ããããïŒãåäžã p-xxiiïŒ
ããã®ãé£æºçµç¹ããã€ã¡ãŒãžããã®ããªããªãé£ããããèªäž»ç®¡çã«åºã¥ãçç£çµç¹ãšããŠäºè§£å¯èœã§ãããæ³å®æŠããæ³å®æŠéžé-第3å·» å·¥èæåãïŒ1954 /æ¥ç§ç€ŸåïŒã§æ¬¡ã®ããã«èšããŠãããã®ã«ãããæ³èµ·ããããã®ã§ããã
ããã®çµç¹ïŒäžäžæã®ã®ã«ãïŒã¯äžã€ã®å執ãæã€ããšæãžããä¹ã«ãã€ãŠçžçŠè£å©ã®å¯Šãæ§ããã圌çã¯åçµããŠäºãå©ããã次ã«ã¯ä¹ã«ãã€ãŠå©çã®é åããã»ãŒåççã«ãªããããä¹ãããæ¿ãã貧ã®æžéãã圌çãæã€ããããããŠç¬¬äžã«ã¯å·¥èã®åéšéã®ç¶åçé£çµ¡ãæãããããã®ããšã¯å¡ãŠã®å·¥èãææ©çãªçµ±ãŒã«å°ãã«è³ã£ããçµåã®ç¢ºç«ã¯ææã®é 絊ãã人å¡ã®çµ±èœããçç¢ã®éçšããå質ã®ç¶æããåéšéã®å¯æ¥ãªé£ç¹«ãããã®æšæºã®åäžããåäŸ¡æ Œã®åçåãããã®è²©å£²ããæ¯çã®çµ±å¶ã容æã«ããåããã区åºãªãã®ã«ãããããïŒãååãšçµç¹ãp184-p185ïŒ
ãã ããå ±æŠ®ãæšãšãã秩åºã厩ããããå·¥èã¯ä¹ã«äŒŽã€ãŠãŒéã«äœèœããŠè¡ã€ãããã®åŽ©æœ°ãå°ãããã®ã¯ãæå·¥èã«æŒããŠã¯åå±ã®å¶åºŠã§ãããæ©æ¢°å·¥æ¥ã«æŒããŠã¯åæ¥äž»çŸ©ã«ããè³æ¬å¶åºŠã§ãã€ããäœããå人ã®å©çãäž»çŒãšããå ±æŠ®ã®çæ³ãç Žããã®ã§ãã€ããå人䞻矩ã¯å¥å šãªå·¥èã®æ®åãäžå¯èœã«ãããããïŒãåäžã p185-p186ïŒ
ããããããäžäžæã®ã®ã«ãããã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã®èšããé£æºçµç¹ããšç¹ããããšã«ã€ããŠãæ代é¯èª€ã®ç©ºæ³è«ãšããŠçä»ããŠããŸãã®ã¯ãã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã®èªã瀟äŒææ©äœäžåç¯åãã€ã¡ãŒãžã§ããªãããã§ãããããã®ç¹ã«ã€ããŠã¯ããŸãåŸã®æ¬èæ¬è«ïŒœã«å ¥ã£ãŠãã觊ããããšã«ãªããšæãããããã§ã¯ãããŒããŒãã»ãªãŒãã®ãã¢ãããºã ã®å²åŠãïŒ1968/æ³æ¿å€§åŠåºçå±åïŒã«ããã次ã®ãããªææã玹ä»ããŠããããããŠããè³éåŽåïŒè ïŒããæç«ãããè¿ä»£è³æ¬äž»çŸ©ç€ŸäŒãããã人éæ¬æ¥ã®çµæžç掻ã®ããæ¹ãæªããŠããæŽå²çã«ç¹æ®ãªçµæžå¶åºŠã§ããããšãèããŠã¿ãå¿ èŠããããã
ãã¢ããã¹ãã¯äººéã®å¯äžæ§ãèªãã人éãåèãšã®éã§è¿œæ±ããå ±æãšçžäºæ¶å©ãé床ãšããŠçµç¹ã蚱容ãããããã§çŸã«ã¢ããã¹ãã¯ã瀟äŒå¥çŽã®ä»£ããã«æ©èœå¥çŽãæèµ·ããå¥çŽã®æš©åšã¯ç¹å®ã®æ©èœã®éè¡ã«ã ãéããããæ¿æ²»çäžå è«è ãããã¯æš©åšäž»çŸ©è ã¯ãç»äžæ§ã匷èŠããçµç¹äœãšããŠç€ŸäŒããšããããã¢ããã¹ãã«ãšã£ãŠã瀟äŒãšã¯è«žéå£ã®åè¡¡ãªããã¯èª¿åã§ããããããŠãããããã®ã»ãšãã©ã¯äžã€ãããã¯ãã以äžã®éå£ã«å±ããŠãããå¯äžã®å°é£ã¯çžäºé¢ä¿ã®èª¿åã§ããããïŒãã¢ããŒããºã ã®é説ïŒ1941ïŒãp166ïŒ
ãçŸä»£ãé¢ããŠãããšãã°äžäžãžè¡ã£ãŠã¿ããšãããã«ã¯äžå®å šãªãããæ©èœçãªç€ŸäŒçµç¹ãå¯èœãªããšã瀺ãå®äŸãã¿ãããããã®æŒžé²çãªå®æã¯è³æ¬äž»çŸ©ã®åèã®ããã«åŠšããããã®ã ãã¯ããããã³ã瀺ããããã«ãä»ã®æ代ãä»ã®ç€ŸäŒåœ¢æ ããŸããæ©èœéå£éã®çžé¢é¢ä¿ã®èª¿åãå¯èœã§ããããšããååã«ç¢ºèšŒããŠããããïŒãåäžã p167ïŒ
ã4ãäžåç¯åããã瀟äŒææ©äœã«ãããã粟ç¥ç掻ãšããŠã®åŽåã
ãã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒãæ§æ³ãã瀟äŒææ©äœäžåç¯åã®ããšã§ã¯ããè³éåŽåïŒè ïŒã®æ¶æ» ããšããããšããåŽååååã®åžå Žç察䟡ãšããŠã®ãè³éããããåŽåææã®æ¥çžŸç察䟡ãšããŠã®ãå ±é ¬ããžã®è»¢æã®ã¿ãæå³ããŠããããã§ã¯ãªããããã®ã¿ã§ãããªãã°ãããæå³ãä»ãµãã®æ¥çžŸäž»çŸ©ã»èœå䞻矩ã«å ããŠããŸãã
ãã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã®èªããè³éåŽåïŒè ïŒã®æ¶æ» ããšã¯ãåæã«ãçèšç¶æãç®çãšããâåŽåâãã®ãã®ã®å€å®¹ã§ããã人éæ¬æ¥ã®åŽåã®ããã¹ã姿ãšããŠã®ã粟ç¥ç掻ãšããŠã®åŽåããžã®æ ¹æ¢çãªè»¢æãæå³ããŠãããããã«ãã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã®äººéçåŽåã«é¢ããæ·±ãæŽå¯åããããŠããã®ç€ŸäŒè«ã®ç¬èªæ§ãšæ®éæ§ãç§ããããŠãããã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã¯æ¬èæ¬è«ïŒœãåã«ããŠæ¬¡ã®ããã«èšãããã®ããšã瀺åããŠããã
ã人éãšäººéãé£æºçµç¹ãšé£æºçµç¹ã®é¢ä¿ã¯ãåŽåã®åãã§åœ¢æããããã®åœ¢æã«ãã£ãŠãåŽåããè ã®æ欲ãæ¶è²»ããè ã®å©çãä¿éãããããïŒãçµæžç掻ã«ãããé£æºçµç¹ãp-xxiiiïŒ
ããã®ãããªé£æºå ±åäœãæ±ããããšããè¡åã¯ã人éæ¬æ§ãåœå®¶ã®å¹²æžãåããªãéãããã®ããšçããŠãããä»æ¹ãèªç±ãªç²Ÿç¥ç掻ãããã«çµã³ã€ãããšããããªããªãèªç±ãªç²Ÿç¥ç掻ã¯ããã®ãããªå ±åäœã®äžã§åœ¹ã«ç«ã¡ãããšé¡ãããã§ããããïŒãåäžã p-xxiiiïŒ
ã粟ç¥ç掻ãèªç±ã§ããã°ããã®ç²Ÿç¥ç掻åºæã®åãæå¹ã«åãããããšãã§ããããããŠãé£æºçã«åœ¢æãããçµæžçµç¹ã§ããã°ãé£æºçµç¹ã®äžã§çµæžäŸ¡å€ãæå¹ã«åãããããšãã§ãããçµæžç掻ã®äžã§å人ãããªããã°ãªããªãããšã¯ãçµæžçã«é£æºããŠãã人ãã¡ãšã®å ±åç掻ããçããŠãããããã«ãã£ãŠãèªåã®ä»äºã«èŠåã£ãä»æ¹ã§ãçµæžç掻ã«é¢äžããããïŒã粟ç¥ç掻ãšçµæžç掻ã®é£æºãp-xxvïŒ
ã以äžã®è«è¿°ã ãã§ã¯ãã粟ç¥ç掻ãšããŠã®åŽåããšããã€ã¡ãŒãžã¯æŽã¿ã¥ããããæ¬è«ïŒœã«ãããŠã詳ããã¯è«ããããŠããªãããç§ã®ç解ã¯âŠâŠäžåç¯åããã瀟äŒææ©äœã«ããããèªç±ãªç²Ÿç¥ç掻ãã®ããšã§ã¯ã人éæ¬æ¥ã®ç€ŸäŒæå¿ïŒå ±åäœã®äžã§åœ¹ç«ã¡ããïŒãšããŠãèªããšé£æºçµç¹ã«ãããåŽåãžã®è¡åã»æ欲ãèœçããâŠâŠãšããæå³ã§ã®ã粟ç¥ç掻ãšããŠã®åŽåããšããããšã ãããããããã§ã®ã粟ç¥ç掻ãšããŠã®åŽåãã«ãæ¥çš®ã»è·çš®çã«ããå·®ç°ã¯ãªãã
ããã®ãããªã粟ç¥ç掻ãšããŠã®åŽåããšããæ§æ³ã«å¯ŸããŠã¯âŠâŠçèšç®çïŒç掻ã®ããã®åå ¥ç¢ºä¿ïŒã®åŽåãã粟ç¥ç掻ããªã®ããšããçåïŒçèšç¶æãšããçµæžç掻ãã®ãã®ã§ãªããïŒïŒããããŠãåŽåãžã®è¡åã»æ欲ã人éæ¬æ¥ã®ç€ŸäŒæå¿ãšããŠèŠãããšãžã®çåïŒäººéã¯å æ¥ã瀟äŒïŒä»è ïŒã®çºã«åãæ欲ãªã©ãªãã®ã§ã¯ãªããïŒïŒâŠâŠãšãã¶ãã声ããã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒåœæããä»æ¥ãŸã§é£ç¶¿ãšç¶ãã
ã第äžã®çåã«ã€ããŠã¯âŠâŠã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã®æ§æ³ããäžåç¯åããã瀟äŒææ©äœã®ããšã«ãããŠãç掻ã®ããã®åå ¥ã¯ç€ŸäŒçã»å ¬å ±çã«çããä¿éãããïŒãããããããŒã·ãã¯ã€ã³ã«ã ãïŒâŠâŠãã®ãšããŠç§ã¯ç解ããããã®çµæãåŽåææã«å¯ŸããŠåŸããããå ±é ¬ããçµæžéçšã§æ ã圹å²èªäœãçèšç¶æãäž»ç®çãšãããè³éããšã¯ç°ãªãæ§æ Œãæã€ããšã«ãªãã§ããããã€ãŸãããå ±é ¬ããšããŠåŸããã貚幣ã¯ãçèšã®ããã®çæŽ»è²¡è³Œå ¥ã®ããã®æ±ºæžãæ ãããšããããäž»ãšããŠãæ°ããªçµæžæŽ»åã«åããŠã®æè³ãèè³ãæ ããããã«ã¯ã瀟äŒççžäºæ¶å©ãšããŠã®èŽäžãæ ãããšã«ãªããã
ã第äºã®çåã¯é£é¢ã§ãããç§èªèº«ãä»ã§ãããããæ³ãã«ãã°ãã°é¥ããããããããããåããã«ããæâŠâŠã粟ç¥ç掻ãšããŠã®åŽåããšããæ§æ³èªäœããå®ã¯ãèªç±ãªç²Ÿç¥ç掻ã«ãã£ãŠè²ãŸãã人éæ¬æ¥ã®ã瀟äŒæå¿ãã®çºé²ãªã®ã§ããããã®ã瀟äŒæå¿ããæ¯ããŠããã®ã¯ãã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã®éæ§è«ã«ãããå¡æºãããæå¿ããªã®ã âŠâŠãšããæ°ä»ãã«æãããŠãããããããæ°ä»ãã«å¯ŸããŠããã·ã¥ã¿ã€ããŒã®èšèãïŒé«æ©èš³ã飯å¡ç·š/2014/æ¥ç§ç€ŸåïŒã«çŽ¹ä»ãããŠãã次ã®ãããªèšèã¯ãç§ãžã®å±ãŸããšãªãã
ãçŸä»£ã®èª²é¡ã¯ãå人ãã¿ãããã®å ãªãè¡åããå šäœã®ããã«åãããã«ãªãããšãªã®ã§ãããã©ããªæ代ã«ã劥åœãããããªç€ŸäŒåé¡ã®è§£æ±ºæ³ãæ¢ãããããå¿ èŠã¯ãªãã®ã ããã èªåã®çããŠããä»ã®æ代ã®çŽæ¥çãªå¿ èŠã ãããµãŸããŠã瀟äŒçã«æèãã掻åããã°ãããïŒäžç¥ïŒç²Ÿç¥ããµããç«ãããäžç芳ããããªãéããç©è³ªäžã®è±ãããä¿ããŠãããè«žå¶åºŠã§ããã°ããã»ã©ããã®äžã§çãã人ã¯èª°ã§ãå©å·±äž»çŸ©ã匷ããããããªãããããŠãã®çµæã次第ã«å°çª®ãäžå¹žã貧å°ãçã¿åºãããããïŒã第äºã®ããã ã®ããã«ã¯ãããã p259-p260ïŒ
ãç¶ãã